e-Teaching
Online Teaching : The e-Teaching Community
Created on: 02 July, 2009 Members: 33099 | Community Link: http://e-teaching.wiziq.com

Apple iPad and its impact on education

by Harman Singh
Posted on 28 January, 2010

I was up late in the night (in India) to watch the launch of iPad and of course reading the tweets which were running at a 100/sec rate!
Here's a video for those who haven't see the iPad yet:



It was a much anticipated release from Apple and as Steve Jobs puts it, "Our most advanced technology in a magical and revolutionary device at an unbelievable price", truly fits the description of the product, in my view.
Just so you know, it starts at $499 - a very reasonable price point considering Netbooks are priced around that.
You can see the pricing and features at Apple's iPad website.
I have spend hours reading about the device and watching videos, both from apple and commentaries of tech enthusiasts. And here's my opinion: Its going to spark a revolution in personal computing, impacting every industry, especially education - for one simple reason: it gives you the mobility of a cell phone with the screen of a computer.
I believe, this device and very soon its counterparts by competitors like HP, Sony etc., will be in the hands of a significant population, especially the students. I can only beging to imagine its possibilities in the education industry, and hence on WiZiQ.
I would like your thoughts on this, not just iPad but the whole new category of "mobile tablets" in regard to the education industry.

Tags: Apple iPad, education, tablet, mobile learning

by Forrest Greenwood posted on 28 January, 2010
I grew up next to a public library in America - every town had one. Public libraries lend books (usually for two weeks) for free. They are supported by the town, state and federal government - they still exist. What I think is imperative for America is that these lending libraries lend out digital downloads just as they do with paper books now. If we don't do this, we will all be Bazosed and Jobbed into reading what sells (at first adopter prices) and that can't be good.

I know universities are slowly working on lending digital text books for up to a year.

Blio, software which allows the reading of text across machines, may be a game changer. Competition (Apple, Amazon, Sony et.al.), will drive machine cost down, Blio may drive book costs down.

Competition, from what I've seen of the ipad, may be Apple's biggest contribution.
by Kirsten Winkler posted on 28 January, 2010
The impact of tablet devices on the society as a whole cannot be estimated high enough although I have to say that I am a bit disappointed of the version 1.0 as I had expected an integrated webcam. But hey, that's Steve. Let the early adopters buy it and then 6 month later I will bring the beefed up version. :)

Fuzemeeting already announced their iPad version of their webmeeting software today and I think others will follow soon. WiZiQ is of course a perfect match for a device like this but I agree that the real shift, the mass effect will be driven by the more open PC world.

The interesting part for me was the pricing as it sets the bar very low for companies like HP, Asus and others who want to offer their own tablets. If you take the classic pricing logic of Apple compared to PC they need to offer their devices for around $249 USD which of course would be awesome for the users.

So I would not say that the iPad itself will change society but the need to have one that Apple builds up with it.

Side effects are: Kindle is dead, newspapers and magazines might survive, textbooks will get cheaper, so will books and movies. Libraries and bookstores will die out as well as newspaper delivery in the morning, junk mail and classic letters.

Yesterday was for sure was a day we, people involved in building a new education sysyem, will remember.
by Carmella Doty posted on 30 January, 2010
I am disappointed that there the IPAD can not multitask and does not have a built in webcam like other Apple products. It is missing these two features.
by Sid posted on 30 January, 2010
The issue with iPad is that it is not too small to carry in pocket and is big enough to warrant a bag. Now if I am going to carry a bag, I would carry my laptop or netbook which can do more functions more efficiently than iPad.

Apple has great products in iPhone and iPod Touch. These two devices will be the biggest competitor of iPad.
by Sid posted on 28 January, 2010
Well I personally do not find any thing in iPad to justify the hype surrounding it. It's just a iPhone on steroids.

iPad is certainly not a first in line of tablet devices as there have been plenty of failed attempts at this technology in past. There have already been question marks raised on the actual usage of this device. Kindle might feel heat and Jobs himself said in the launch that they will be standing on shoulders of Kindle.

Will it affect WiZiQ community. I highly doubt it will. iPad does not supports Flash which is essentially what our Virtual Classroom is based on and there are all the indications from Apple which suggest that arrival of Flash on either iPhone or iPad will be a bumpy ride.

The rise of Open Sourced Android along with HTML5 & Flash will eventually challenge the market position of Apple.

On a lighter note though, Fred Wilson has already found a right place for iPad in case he had to choose between Nexus One and iPad, his elliptical trainer.
This would be better for people who find the iPhone too small.
by Kapil Mehta posted on 28 January, 2010
Dear Harman-
Yes with the world going mobile and carrying with it flashy yet simple to use devices like I-PAD, a lot of walls that clouded the spread of education will be gutted down. The concern is Apple (which I and you love) and its ever increasing roster of imitators are a bit choosy and often dictate their own terms before it lets application developers make software for the device. With such turbulence happening and following increasing by day to personalize computing by making it more tailor made (as every one cant be tech savvy) and simplifying technologies, will business interests offset the bigger good to expand education on line.

Will the consumer preferences change fast? especially in India and down south of it, is something that I still feel creates frost around my understanding.

Having said that Apple firmly redefines the rules of the game and by the time you realize it sweeps you off your feet.

Take good care-
Kapil
by David Friedman posted on 01 February, 2010
I agree with Forrest that it would be great if it were possible to borrow digital books.

Something similar to Safari Books but for a larger body of work:
http://my.safaribooksonline.com/

Also I wonder sometimes about the traditional publishing model. The idea is that a person (let's say Stephen King) spends x numbers of hours writing a book. He gets advances from the publisher but ultimately he's getting paid when the book is released, and his proceeds depend on his sales.

Stephen King doesn't advocate a political point of view but his focus is mostly to entertain.

But there may be many instances today where people care less about how many sales they make, and more about how persuasive their ideas are.

http://www.amazon.com/Sam-Walton-Made-America/dp/0553562835

Walton obviously did not need the money – but he wrote the book to talk about the company and the business that he devoted so much time to and loved.

http://www.amazon.com/Wal-Mart-Way-Success-Largest-Company/dp/0785261192

Similarly I don't think Soderquist needed the money – but he wanted to try to preserve Walmart culture.

http://www.amazon.com/What-Angel-Taught-You-Fulfillment/dp/1578191343/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1265052065&sr=1-1

Rabbi Noah Weinberg probably cared more about how many people he could bring to Orthodox Judaism then how many sales of his book there were. The more books that he sold the more potential people he could bring back to Orthodoxy but he goal was religious not financial.

http://www.amazon.com/Black-Swan-Impact-Highly-Improbable/dp/1400063515/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1265052149&sr=1-

Taleb has plenty of money. He wants to sell books, but I think he would rather see change in behavior than greater book sales.

http://www.amazon.com/Misbehavior-Markets-Fractal-Financial-Turbulence/dp/0465043577/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1265052199&sr=1-
1-spell

I don't think Benoit Mandlebrot wrote the book to get rich. In fact I think he said in the preface that there are only a handful of people (at a central bank in Europe) who make decisions which affect hundreds of millions. He hoped to influence those people, and to help create scientific dialog.

http://www.amazon.com/Dead-Aid-Working-Better-Africa/dp/0374139563/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1265053001&sr=1-1 –

Dambisa Moyo is advocating a change in policy with respect to aid for Africa. She very well may care more about whether her book causes policy changes then whether she makes profit from it (I believe she worked at a high position in an investment brokerage firm).

So I think in these examples the people wrote the book (perhaps in part to make money), but also to persuade people of a certain point of view, or to change their behavior – what they do and how they see the world.

They could offer the books for free and they would probably get a larger audience (David Roodman is offering a book on microfinance for free)

http://blogs.cgdev.org/open_book/category/about-the-bookoutline

but on the other hand even if they get a larger audience that additional audience may or may not contribute to a productive dialog.

The reasoning may be that if somebody is going to devote their time to listen to the argument, they are probably willing to fork over the $15 or $20 to hear it.

On another topic, I don't know for sure but I'd conjecture that a great deal of the cost of books today is the advertising.

When I was a graduate school I heard a talk by Eric Brill of Microsoft and he said the most expensive commodity in computing today is human attention.

People, books, websites, etc. are competing for human attention. I'm reading a book by Alan Greenspan called The Age of Turbulence. He says that coffee makers compete with soda and beer. They are competing for their share of the human stomach.

With this new iPad device maybe people will consider a model where the book is initially more expensive, is then cheaper, and is then zero (free, in the public domain).
by David Jones posted on 30 January, 2010
Forrest,

I agree with you that the Public Library needs to modernize and change with the times. My local library in Canada allows users to search for books and renew books that have been taken out through their website. Over the last couple of years they have started offering digital versions of some books to be downloaded as well as being able to download audio books. I still prefer reading a physical book to reading something on my computer or a mobile device like the iPad, but I do often make use of the audio books. It's nice to be able to listen to a book on the daily commute!
Would you like to Reply:
Sign Up, or  Sign In (if you are existing member) to join this community!

See Virtual Classroom in action

Get a hands-on look at how WizIQ Virtual Classroom works.

Try Virtual Classroom Now

Request a free demo

Give live classes, create & sell online courses

Try it free Plans & Pricing

Connect